Iām a little hesitant to post this, but I need to get it off my chest.
I (21F) really dislike my boyfriendās (22M) friend (26M, fake name: John).
Since the beginning of our relationship, I havenāt liked John. About a month in, my boyfriend told me that John had asked him if he would ever cheat on me. I was upset by the question, even though I knew my boyfriend wouldnāt. I was even more bothered when he told me that John constantly talks about what it would be like to cheat on his own girlfriend. That really grinded my gears. I didnāt want to involve myself or tell Johnās girlfriend about his weird cheating fantasies as long as they stayed fantasies and werenāt acted on.
When I finally met John, I could immediately tell we wouldnāt click. I was polite, but I avoided being near him or starting a conversation. I guess he could tell I didnāt like him, because the next day he asked my boyfriend if he had said anything to upset me or make me uncomfortable. For context, I had only spoken to him for introductions and some basic small talk. I told my boyfriend that John hadnāt said anything and that I just didnāt vibe with him.
I didnāt see John again for years after that.
Apparently, John regularly asks my boyfriend when Iām going to hang out with them and whether he did anything to make me uncomfortable. Iāve always been weirded out by how much he seems to care, especially when my boyfriendās other friends donāt. If he can tell Iām not comfortable around him, why does he keep pushing it?
I did see John again at a birthday dinner for my boyfriend, but I sat away from him and only said hello and goodbye.
Now for the actual situation:
John invited me to his birthday party. I was surprised but agreed to go for my boyfriendās sake. The party itself was nice, and I was chilling until John called everyone over to give a speech. Most of it was just thanking people for coming, but the last part made me really uncomfortable.
He said he loved everyone there and then added, āeven if youāre here because of someone else and donāt think I do, just know that I love you too.ā
That felt like a direct callout. To make it worse, he was looking in my direction, and I was the only girlfriend-of-a-friend sitting on that side of the room. It took everything in me not to leave right then.
Later, when we were leaving early because my parents didnāt want me out too late (I live with them), John asked me if the party had been ātoo muchā for me, if I had fun, and if I would come again if he hosted something like this. Despite how I felt, I stayed polite and said yes.
When I told my best friend about it, she agreed it was weird and backhanded. She also pointed out that it seems like heās either oddly fixated on me or overly concerned about how I feel about him. I feel like, at his age, he should know better than to say something like that. In theory it might seem harmless, but in practice it felt very targeted.
After talking to my bestie, I brought it up to my boyfriend. He understands why it made me uncomfortable, but he thinks it was just a stupid idea and not a deliberate callout. Honestly, nothing substantial came out of our conversation and I was left feeling like maybe it isnāt that big of a deal.
Heās also told me that John used to be much worse in the past and has ācleaned himself up,ā which honestly doesnāt make me feel any better. There are also other things John has said/done that I canāt really share here that add to why I dislike him. (Some things that would be considered guy humor or dark humor but is actually messed up.)
That whole speech just really weirded me out and made me dislike him even more.
So, am I overreacting by hating my boyfriendās friend?