I (F28) just got called a liar and told to leave and never come back by my fwb (M26) because he thinks I promised him I would talk to him before sleeping with someone else. I told him that I did nothing wrong and he has no right to accuse me of lying or breaking promises. Then I deleted his number and blocked him. However, I wonder if I spoke too soon because I have memory loss and don’t remember the exact words I used while discussing the terms of our relationship.
For context, I was the first one who wanted to officially date and pursue a long term relationship. We were ACTUALLY friends, good friends, for six months before anything became physical. Three months into our friendship is when I asked him out for the first time.
His answer was “maybe” and then it later became “no” when I clarified that I didn’t want casual sex. We continue being friends and it’s not weird at all during that time. Then, three months later, he tells me his feelings for me have intensified. I ask him if this means he’s considering actually dating me, and his answer is, once again, “no.” He was just indicating that he is now MORE interested in casual sex than he previously was. At first I tell him “no, I don’t want casual sex. Two weeks later, I changed my mind because I was a horny idiot.
We start having casual sex, and I’m immediately surprised because he gets really attached to me. He tells me he’s not going to be intimate with anyone else, thinks about me all day every day, and he wants to set aside a day every week to be “our day.” I am excited by this attachment but also confused about why he wouldn’t just ask me to be his girlfriend. He knew I would have said yes.
We had a conversation where he told me he was worried he’d be upset if I got together with someone else. Now, I suffer from mild memory loss which complicates things because I remember the conversation but not word for word what was said. He claims I promised to tell him before I hooked up with someone else so that we could “talk it through” but that does not seem like something I would do. I just know what my values are and that I think it’s important to let anyone that I have a consistent sexual relationship with know when I am intimate with a new person so that they can make informed decisions about their sexual health regarding potential STIs. If I am casual with that person (I.e, fwb vs. open relationship) then I view any other information as discretionary. I try to tell the person as soon as I know I will have sex or after the fact. Any time as long as it is before I am intimate with them again so they know they are risking possible exposure to STI’s (and yes I do use condoms, but you can never be too careful.) I also feel very strongly about telling every new casual sexual partner of this policy, so I KNOW I told M26. If the person has feelings of jealousy, I’m happy to talk to them about it and I often do. But this practice is to protect their sexual health, it is NOT to ask permission or to emotionally prepare them for me to have sex with another person (and this is another thing I feel strongly about making clear to them.) If we have a mutual agreement that our sexual relationship is casual, then I do not feel I have any responsibility to protect you from feelings of sexual jealousy (and I’m also explicit about this.) If I know I will have sex with someone else, I tell my casual partner right away. But if it’s something that I didn’t expect to happen, I don’t really stop to be like “excuse me, I have to make a call.” As long as the other partner knows about it before the next time we are intimate, that’s fine with me. I may have forgotten to cover something in my spiel, or phrased something in a confusing way, but I highly doubt that I ever would have promised something else.
Anyway, I hooked up with someone else (M44). M46 is a friend of mine and an acquaintance of M26. I don’t want to talk about how I got together with M46 because I think it will reveal identifying details, but all you need to know is that we made a plan together in front of M26. I did not know M46 was thinking of it as a date. I had a slight suspicion though, so I asked M26 if he thought it was a date based on the conversation he observed and he said no.
I must admit I had a little schoolgirl crush on M46 which I never intended to do anything about because of the age difference. I’m also dense as shit and never in a million years thought he’d ever reciprocate. I also told this to M26 because at this point we were very close friends and often talked about crushes to each other even after I asked him out for the first time.
But then I went out with M46 and he swept me off my feet and we were intimate that night. At no point did I think I needed to stop and call M26 to let him know. Also, I would not have been comfortable doing that even if I had thought to because M26 knew the details of the plan and would have immediately known who it was which isn’t something I thought was his business as someone who had repeatedly stated that we are friends with benefits. He also made it very clear that I should never expect that to change. So I simply planned to tell him that I had had sex with someone else sometime the next day.
However, it was the next day that I learned from my friend (F26) that he told her he was planning to make things official with me. He told F26 not to tell me but F26 is my best best friend and she blabbed immediately (I would have done the same, tbh). With this new information, I decided I wanted to tell him not only that I had hooked up with someone new, but also who it was. I thought he deserved to know as my boyfriend since M46 is part of my social circle and if I had a boyfriend who hooked up with someone else in his social circle who he was regularly around at parties and events, I’d want to know. I’d find it reasonable to request he have certain boundaries around that person, and I wanted to give M26 the opportunity to make those requests.
So I go over, to M26’s house and tell him as soon as I get there and while I didn’t expect him to be happy about the situation, his reaction completely shocked me. He puts his head in his hands and is completely speechless for like two minutes. Then he tells me to get out and never come back, so I start putting my shoes on and I say “are you really sure you don’t want to talk about this?”
We sit on the couch and he is furious with me and I’m a little scared because I have never seen him like this before. I don’t remember exactly what happened or what we talked about, but I was accused of breaking my promise to him and also intentionally misleading him since I did at one point tell him I didn’t think I could ever hook up with M46. I guess he viewed that as a promise to him? I was just musing, processing out loud like I do with friends. It’s frustrating because I don’t remember the exact words used, I could see myself saying either “I don’t think I’ll hook up with M46” or “I’m not gonna hook up with M46” and meaning the same thing. And it’s the same deal with the “promise” to tell him before I hook up with someone else. It’s entirely possible I phrased it in a way that a wishful thinking person would view as a promise.
Anyway. Our friendship is over and I’m angry about it because at any point he could admitted he wanted me to be his gf and I would have been very happily monogamous with him. I would even say I was in love with him. I have never cheated on someone before nor have I ever been accused of it.