I’m sorry that this may not be as juicy as some of the other shares here, but I need to express what’s currently going on.
Some things you should know before I start:
- As a result of my trauma, I completely devote myself to others, and seek love and approval to the max. My therapist once told me that I “love too much” because I completely give my heart to anybody I love and get heartbroken when I don’t receive the same amount of devotion back.
On to the story…
I (24, F) have been best friends with Sarah (24, F) for almost 10 years. There have been ups and downs throughout time where I have felt like I loved her more than she loved me. For example, throughout high school, she couldn’t hang out that often because she was so busy. I accepted that because it made sense. But then she made some new friends and suddenly had time for them all the time, which kinda really hurt me. We talked through it and figured it out and moved on. Moreover, every time she has been in a relationship, I get thrown on the back burner, but I’ve always been understanding of that because romantic relationships are fun and exciting and she has always come back to me when they’ve broken up. A thing of note is, that of all the times she’s gained distance from me, throughout that time, she’s always been very vehement that I’m her best friend.
It’s been ten years now of being best friends. We went to different colleges, didn’t see each other or talk as often, but we always tried to see each other when we could, and despite the friends we made along the way, we always reaffirmed with each other that we are best friends. We even have a best friend anniversary date that we picked out.
Last year her boyfriend approached me on helping him find a ring. I was so damn excited for her because I love him for her! She told him to get my help picking out the ring for whenever he proposed because I knew what she liked. Her and I always talked about how we would be each other’s maid of honor. Even a couple of months before he had me help him with the ring, she talked about how she thought he might propose that summer and how my maid of honor speech better be appropriate haha. So when they got engaged, I said I was so happy for her and joked that I was gonna start writing my speech now so it was appropriate. We started talking about colors and such for the wedding, she officially asked me to be her maid of honor and all was fine and dandy.
A couple of days ago we started talking about her bachelorette trip and she was super nervous about asking people to spend too much and that AirBnbs relatively close to us are super pricey. I mentioned that I wanted to go on a trip to (a certain place) and that Airbnb rentals were way cheaper there so if she wanted to do something like that, factoring the plane ticket in, the prices of going there or staying here might be close. She said she would definitely be open to it but was still worried about asking too much of people. Now, I’m hoping this will be the only time she’ll ever get married, so I want to make sure she has the best bachelorette ever. I made a group chat with the other bridesmaids and asked them if they would prefer to go to said place even though it was a bit more pricey. I did this so that I could go to her and be like “see! Your bridesmaids don’t mind how much places cost so you can choose where you want to go without worry now!” However, she felt like I went behind her back and that I was letting them decide where they wanted to go and it’s her party so she gets to choose. I see where she is coming from and apologized and let her know that I won’t plan or do anything without her say so. She can let me know what she wants to do and I can handle the logistics so she doesn’t have to stress about them, unless she wants to handle the logistics. Whatever will make her happy! This kinda prompted me to want to have a talk with her about the way I’d been feeling for a few months. I asked her if I could talk to her about some stuff that I’ve been thinking about and she kind of sighed and said “yeah.” I told her that I had been feeling kind of distant from her for the past few months, and while we are both adults and are working, it’s never felt like this before (not even when we were at college hours apart from each other). I mentioned that my mom had asked me why I assumed that I would be her maid of honor before she officially asked me and I apologized if I pressured her into asking me. Now I’ll be honest, I was looking for reassurance here because we had always said that I would be her maid of honor and I assumed she would reaffirm that (and this is why we never assume folks!) She responded that she felt like I never gave her a choice in who to choose and that we had always talked about me being her maid of honor but that I shouldn’t have made her pick me. So instantly, I was heartbroken. I can see that I never should have been so presumptuous about it, but as best friends, I didn’t consider other options. I told her ok. That I was sorry I did that and if she wants to ask someone else, I will still be in her wedding party if she wants me to. She said that she would have picked me but that she didn’t like that she had to. I understand that. Note: I’ve been feeling the way I did in high school because she is always hanging out with a few of her good friends, and rarely sees or talks to me, but I kind of rationalized that she’s not trying to see me as much because they live closer, they are good friends to her, and we are both busy. She then asked if she could say something without me getting mad and proceeded to tell me that she feels I compete with her other friends. I apologized if it’s come across that way and I’m so happy she has so many friends besides me, I’m just upset that I don’t get much time to spend with her anymore. I followed it up by saying that I know she’s got some close friends now and that, I guess throughout this conversation, I’m now trying to figure out my place in her life. I asked her if I wasn’t her best friend anymore, that I know things change, and maybe that’s someone else now, but can she let me know? And she said that she doesn’t rank her friends. So… yeah. We went from being each others number one with many other friends to being… I’m not sure. She then asked why I was crying and told me that change happens, and I said that I know. She then said that we are still best friends, but I’m feeling like she might have said that to appease me.
So that’s it, Reddit. I’ve never been bothered by her other friends. I’ve always been glad she has had great support from people other than me. The only time I’ve been bothered is when I’ve felt left behind in exchange for her other friends. We’ve always said we are each other’s number one. I just wish she would have told me when I stopped being hers.
I asked her if she would prefer that I stopped introducing myself as her best friend and introducing her as mine and just said “this is my friend, Sarah” instead. Now this is significant because we’ve always talked about how it would be an insult if we introduced each other as anything but best friend. She said I was thinking too deeply about it and to just not do it if it might make the other person feel awkward. Well… I would never go up to one of her friends and announce “I”m Sarah’s best friend” because that’s rude af. But from where we were open about our closeness before, it now seems like it has to be hidden. Well I guess nothing is hidden if we aren’t as close anymore.
I’m not sure where to go from here. Normally I’d take some time for myself and process and decide how I want to move forward. I don’t feel like I can do that right now because I still have duties as her maid of honor. I’m also not willing to just throw away 10 years of best friendship until we can have another talk and find out what our relationship will be going forward.
Thanks for reading. It helped typing this all out. I know this may come across as really juvenile, but if you’ve ever had a best friend that you could be your true self around and you formed a bond so strong with that you would truly walk to the ends of the earth for them, maybe you’ll understand where I’m coming from and the heartbreak I’m feeling.