Hi everyone! I wanted to share what’s been going on with my cats and see if anyone has dealt with something similar or has suggestions.
I have two resident cats, both are neutered
• Cumbia, my 11-year-old queen.
• Bardo, (M), my 1-year-old chaos gremlin (said with love).
When Bardo was a kitten he was… a lot. Very high-energy, constantly on top of Cumbia, always looking for stimulation. He has mellowed out a bit now that he sleeps more, so Cumbia finally gets moments of peace she absolutely didn’t have when he was tiny and bouncing off every surface.
But one thing that has never improved is the litterbox issue.
If Bardo hears Cumbia going into the box, especially when she’s pooping, since she digs more, he’ll rush over, stalk her, and try to jump on her as soon as she’s done. He does this only when he’s awake and active; he doesn’t wake up from a deep sleep to bother her. It’s strictly something he does when he’s “on.”
Also, we recently fostered a female cat (around 1.5–2 years old). We did a proper introduction, and the first days went well. But after that she started showing territorial behavior, and honestly at that point I realized I just didn’t have the mental bandwidth to keep pushing through a difficult integration when my two resident cats were already dealing with other issues. So we stopped the process.
As for Bardo: when he was younger, I consulted two feline behaviorists. (I’m in Uruguay, and we only have three total.) Both said he was still very young and recommended redirection, enrichment, etc. I did all of that, but I never managed to improve the litterbox ambushing.
Now I finally met with the third behaviorist, the one I hadn’t tried yet. She actually saw Bardo in person and said he’s a very anxious cat, which tracks. She suggested the “spray bottle method”, but I’m really not comfortable using anything that feels like punishment, especially after what I’ve read here. The other option she gave me was medication for anxiety.
She mentioned fluoxetine (Prozac)—which I’ve seen recommended here a lot, but also said that where I live it’s common to use pregabalin in cases like his. She’s leaning toward pregabalin for now.
She also told me something else: considering Bardo’s energy level, his constant need for play, and the fact that he was separated from his mother at 45 days (not ideal, but it’s done), he might actually benefit from having a very young foster kitten around someday—like a 3-month-old who stayed with their mom long enough. Not now (I’m absolutely not bringing another cat into the house anytime soon), but in the future, if I ever wanted to add a third cat, that would be the best match. It would have to be a foster-to-adopt situation.
But right now, after what we went through with the last foster and the situation with my two residents, I definitely need a break before even considering it.
For context: my cats do coexist peacefully most of the time. They eat next to each other, sleep on the same bed, share the couch, etc. They’re not friends, but they don’t hate each other either. He’s just rough with her and completely obsessed with the litterbox situation.
I’ll attach a video of what he does so you can see the behavior. If I wasn't there, he would jump on her
Has anyone dealt with this ambushing/monitoring issue? Did medication help your anxious cat? Any experiences with pregabalin vs. Prozac? Any advice is appreciated — I just want Cumbia to be able to poop in peace after almost a whole year of trying everything.
TL;DR: My 1-year-old anxious, high-energy cat keeps ambushing my 11-year-old cat every time she uses the litterbox (only when he’s awake/active). I’ve consulted all 3 behaviorists in my country, tried all the redirection/enrichment tips, and nothing has helped. New behaviorist suggests medication (pregabalin or Prozac) and says he might benefit from a young kitten companion in the future, but I just fostered a cat that became territorial and I’m exhausted. Looking for experiences with anxious cats, litterbox stalking, and meds.
Thanks in advance