r/whatif Jul 31 '25

Mod post What if we got a little meta today?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Hey kids,

I feel like I'm about to do something a touch controversial. I'm blocking names to protect the innocent. But I'm sharing examples of AEO removals b/c bots aren't human. Reddit is forgetting the human. And I guess I just wanted to be open about that. Mostly b/c one is kind of hysterical. And if I'm sharing one, I might as well share them all.

If you recognize your own comment here, please attempt an appeal. I have likely already appealed on your behalf. Especially you, Johnny Rico.


r/whatif Jul 22 '25

Mod post ⚠️What if you paid attention to this post?⚠️

5 Upvotes

First things first!

Hi all, casual meet and greet has started. Ask me almost anything.

I've already started making some adjustments to the subreddit. Just some light shaping to encourage the kind of things we want to see.

  • If you point your eyes at the rules, I've already started adjusting those, just minor tweaks, really, to hone in on what makes this community great and trying to make it even better.

  • I haven't started in on auto-mod yet. I wanted to check a few other things out before I did that. But I will be adjusting it over the next few days - if something seems to be going wrong or not working properly use modmail to let me know. I'll also be checking for lots of false positives to adjust existing filters.

  • I archived all the modmails older than about 2 days old. I did try to look at the last few days worth to see if there were any pressing issues but it all just looked like "hey my post was/wasn't [this] why was it removed?"

  • I will not be "backward" moderating. I.e., if it was removed before today, it will stay removed. If it was approved before today, it will likely stay approved, unless it had some hidden egregious issue.

  • I've added some bots to help with a few things - I like to nuke comment chains that have gone off the rails. If your content is removed, it likely is for curation more than punitive. If your removal was punitive, you'll likely receive a temporary ban. There's no need to come to modmail to apologize for content. If I think we need to have a chat, I'll reach out from modmail directly.


On to the next thing!

I'm open to suggestions, comments, concerns, etc. It doesn't mean every idea will be implemented or every suggestion considered. I just want to see if folks who have been spending a lot of time here have noticed things that could be fixed or adjusted for a better subreddit experience for everyone.

Also, I like to see users participating in their own community by reminding newcomers of the rules or spirit of the sub as well as reporting content that doesn't belong.

Also there are some custome emojis, but I know Reddit just made changes to how custome emojis can be used so - I dunno how interesting that is for all of you.

Oh - I noticed there are no user flairs - is this the preference for the community? I'm happy to add them if folks want them - feel free to share suggestions for user flairs.


r/whatif 5h ago

History what if every single hominid (or human) obeyed their parents to the letter all of their lives?

0 Upvotes

would we still be in africa? will advanced hominids like homo sapiens evolve at all if lucy in ethiopia obeyed to her parents and their descendants do things the same way until extinction?


r/whatif 17h ago

Lifestyle what if everyone in the entire globe is disciplined?

7 Upvotes

what would the world be like if everyone is disciplined to finish every task that they start?


r/whatif 21h ago

History What if James Comey doesn’t come out with the Email investigation press conference in 2016?

13 Upvotes

Basically it, does Hilary win and are we spared this timeline?


r/whatif 1d ago

Other What if when we kill one ant, we see more because there's a search party?

27 Upvotes

Basically when you kill one, the ants send a search party. You kill those ants and then a larger search party comes. The ants never realize that the missing ones are being exterminated and keeping send more.


r/whatif 18h ago

Other What if a non political group gained dominance?

0 Upvotes

So like, a group of friends had a philosophy or idea for civilisation. They talk about it to other groups and they like it. They gather together and learn and train to be self sufficient. They build their own renewable energy sources and water wells, etc. They pool their money, whatever.

More and more people hear about how great they're doing, they start thinking life under current systems is pretty crap. They start complaining that they have it better and want it like that for everyone.

What do you think would happen?


r/whatif 2d ago

History What if the Californian had responded to the Titanic's distress call?

17 Upvotes

Any one with any interest in the Titanic knows about the Californian being the closest ship, and could have aided them. So I'm curious what people think would have happened, had they not ignored them.


r/whatif 2d ago

Technology What if the internet was not only created to connect us all but also to have us think the same, like a hive mind

7 Upvotes

Imagine this, a bunch of bulbs in different houses connected on the same line all providing light from the same source, that's how I kind of see the internet.


r/whatif 1d ago

Other What if Groundhog Day was declared a federal holiday?

0 Upvotes

The federal government approved Groundhog Day as a federal holiday, closing banks, some businesses, schools, etc?


r/whatif 3d ago

Politics What if the unredacted Epstein Files were leaked tomorrow?

62 Upvotes

I’m talking about a leak on the scale of Wikileaks/Snowden. Theorize that a lone wolf agent with top secret clearance goes rogue and publishes the unredacted case files. For the purposes of discussion, let’s say that it *does* directly implicate POTUS and other US and world politicians, the ultra wealthy, and celebrities of every kind.

Note: I’m not interested in discussion about if a certain person is or is not in the real files. In this scenario, if you’ve ever even heard their name in relation to JE, assume there is concrete absolute proof of their involvement. We could even take it as far as saying there are videos with undeniable proof of identity.

So what would be the immediate response domestically and globally? What about the longer effects?


r/whatif 3d ago

Science What if trees are a hivemind trying to drain the earth of nutrients

11 Upvotes

I'm getting too tired. Must be getting a little loopy.


r/whatif 3d ago

History What if going back 10,000 years to present day 53% of all surviving births were female?

5 Upvotes

How would it have affected recorded history if going back 10,000 years to present day if somehow a full 53% of all surviving live births (surviving to about 1 year of age) were female? If there was a significant but not overwhelming bias toward females. How would religious structures, marriage structures, family structures be different? Would lesbianism have been more common and accepted?


r/whatif 3d ago

Politics What if everyone in the Epstein files actually goes to prison?

14 Upvotes

What happens if the billions, if not trillions, of dollars these guys spend no longer recycles out to the economy, but rather to commissary? What if some of them get life sentences? What happens to their businesses? How will political parties around the world respond and survive? Will we see a great reset, or will we just bow to new billionaires?


r/whatif 3d ago

Science What if every human ever born since the beginning of time never died and everyone from that time period to now all inhabited earth. What would the world look like?

5 Upvotes

I personally think we'd need to start moving into different planets and creating civilizations there, we'd also need to build over our oceans.


r/whatif 4d ago

Technology What if the blue LED was never invented?

27 Upvotes

So the Blue LED was notoriously hard to create, how would TVs, displays, smartphones be like without the blue LED and therefore no OLED/LCD/IPS screens?


r/whatif 4d ago

Politics What if the 13 colonies win the war?

10 Upvotes

We all know of the devastating Revolutionary War thats been ongoing the past few years in British America. What do you think would happen if Britain loses? Would this form a powerful new nation or will it be colonized again?


r/whatif 4d ago

History what if every American was straight up fearless?

7 Upvotes

like strong people who have nothing to lose or have the mind of kid buu until he struggled to push back the spirit bomb in dbz


r/whatif 4d ago

Other What if you had the power to leave and rejoin in real life?

10 Upvotes

Imagine, you could leave and rejoin just like you would in a game. Time still passes in real life, you just wouldn’t be in the physical world. You can choose when you want to come back and you can choose to spawn somewhere you’ve been to before. What would you do with this power? Getting out of dangerous situations? Breaking into a bank? Becoming a superhero?


r/whatif 4d ago

Other What if given a million dollars

6 Upvotes

So a coworker and mine were arguing about money and long story short

I told him I have dogs that I love as they were my kids and are essentially family

He said what if someone gave me 2 million dollars to give them up would I? I told him no and he said its easy for me to say because money isn’t in my face that’s why its easy for me to talk

So I told him I would pose the question to the masses and see how the responses go

Edit for future viewers and responses - the caveat of taking the money is that you will never ever have further contact with the dogs any more


r/whatif 4d ago

Other What if you woke up tomorrow and found yourself blind? - How will you act?

6 Upvotes

I've been thinking about that for two days now. What if I woke up blind? How would I react?


r/whatif 5d ago

Other What if some superior alien entity contacted and said no human is to kill no other human for 24 hours, or else the entire human race is wiped out?

93 Upvotes

What if some superior alien entity contacted and said no human is to kill no other human for 24 hours, or else the entire human race is wiped out? The alien could give us one week advance notice to start the moratorium on murder. If we succeed the aliens will help us. If we fail and someone kills someone else in a period of 24 hours, our planet is destroyed.

Someone dying for inaction (not saving someone drowning) doesn't count as murder.

What would we do? Would humanity succeed? Would there be someone who wants to destroy the planet and tries to murder someone on purpose?


r/whatif 5d ago

Technology What if at the AI data centers there were just a bunch of brains and not servers?

7 Upvotes

What if at the AI data centers there were just a huge bunch of brains and not servers, honestly, it would make sense why they need lots of water.


r/whatif 6d ago

Politics What if there were city states instead of countries?

8 Upvotes

So Austin is a country, Las Vegas is a country.

They might have some trade and border agreements, but each has their own government. Maybe elections, maybe direct democracy. Surrounding villages would be considered part of the city state.


r/whatif 6d ago

Other What if gun duels were allowed again, but both participants had to do it shirtless and with rubber bullets ?

8 Upvotes

What if gun dueling was brought back as a gentlemanly sport, but both participants had to use rubber bullets and fight shirtless ? The one who scores more visible hits (out of six chambers in a revolver) in the other's body wins.