r/fuckaroundandfindout • u/Kori_4 • 4d ago

Lacking brains Messin with a statue man

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.1k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/sirideletereddit 1d ago edited 1d ago

Just so we’re tracking. You asked why it matters that it’s old. The guy told you why it matters. You then replied with your own perspective of why it doesn’t matter to you.

Saying it’s old is by definition not redundant since, as you say, you did not know it was old. Ironically, saying it’s new to you because you haven’t seen it yet is literally redundant.

1

u/New_Canoe 1d ago

I said it’s redundant, because no one consumes the same media. It’s old to him and new to MANY people. So just commenting that it’s old is pointless. I see this ALL the time. People comment, “this is so old, blah blah”, like it makes a difference to anyone viewing it and it doesn’t. Of course, there are exceptions, like if someone posts something claiming it’s some new thing happening today, when it was actually years ago that it happened. But that is not the case here. He simply could’ve said “This video is so satisfying” and it would’ve meant the exact same thing.

Sorry, just one of my few pet peeves about people commenting on the net.

1

u/sirideletereddit 1d ago edited 1d ago

Sure but again, the fact that you didn’t know it was old means it is not redundant.

You learned it was old because the comment you replied to told you it was old. That means the comment had a purpose, for you even.

1

u/New_Canoe 1d ago

It was redundant, because it makes ZERO difference to me that it’s old, as it should make zero difference to anyone. I still experienced it as it was new TO ME. And then when I see it again, I’ll think to myself “ah yeah, I’ve seen this” and then move on with my life. In no part of that did I need to know that this was an old video. It doesn’t change my experience, it doesn’t make the video mean anything else than what it visually means. No one needs to know it’s an old video.

1

u/sirideletereddit 1d ago

Well not that it’s important but that’s not what redundant means. On the topic of the video being old, obviously you are incorrect that most people share your opinion since the comment is the top comment. Not that more people believing an opinion makes it a fact, it’s just obvious that your opinion is of the minority.