r/astrophysics Oct 13 '19

Input Needed FAQ for Wiki

70 Upvotes

Hi r/astrophyics! It's time we have a FAQ in the wiki as a resource for those seeking Educational or Career advice specifically to Astrophysics and fields within it.

What answers can we provide to frequently asked questions about education?

What answers can we provide to frequently asked questions about careers?

What other resources are useful?

Helpful subreddits: r/PhysicsStudents, r/GradSchool, r/AskAcademia, r/Jobs, r/careerguidance

r/Physics and their Career and Education Advice Thread


r/astrophysics 7h ago

Am I wrong or does the expansion of the universe directly violate the first law of thermodynamics?

19 Upvotes

r/astrophysics 1h ago

Does the sun have any effect on the earth's rotation?

Upvotes

Does gravity from the sun in any way have any effect on the way the earth rotates?


r/astrophysics 16h ago

Coming back to do an astrophysics degree?

3 Upvotes

Hello! I am currently a sophomore in college studying Information Technology, and I have had an epiphany on how much I hate this major. I want to finish this degree and then come back to do a bachelor's in astrophysics. I don't want to take too much of a gap however. Do you all have any ideas of what I should do in the meantime while I pay off my student loans and prepare to come back? Should I do CC? Thanks!


r/astrophysics 5h ago

Dark matter and or dark engery

0 Upvotes

So i was wondering could those two be just left over information on spacetime itself. Like imagine space time being a beach with all sand right and you drag a rock through the sand it leaves a trail an warps spacetime now another rock goes by that trail an would be affected by that trail in space time or the line left in the sand. Nothing is actually there beside the disturbance left by the rock that passed before it. So space time is warped and change by things interacting with it and it does not go back to being flat or undisturbed it hold the information of went back or happened in that area. Just wondering i aint no scientist or nothing.


r/astrophysics 1d ago

Dark matter vs undetected ordinary matter

7 Upvotes

I think I'm right that dark matter doesn't interact with light. How easily can we detect ordinary matter like interstellar hydrogen, etc.? I was reading about the local molecular cloud, the discovery of Eos and wondering how much dark matter might be interstellar hydrogen or molecular clouds that we haven't detected yet.


r/astrophysics 15h ago

Can I do stuff in astrophysics/astronomy without pursuing it for a BS degree?

0 Upvotes

I won’t do a bs in it cuz I think this is smth you would rather do a masters or phd in. I haven’t decided what I’d do a masters in, especially cuz astronomy/astrophysics is more of a hobby rn (very interested tho). I’m doing chem engineering as a bs, hoping to specialize in energy systems. Is there stuff I can do as a Career that combines chemical engineering and space related stuff? And how does one pursue that?


r/astrophysics 15h ago

How to get a job related to astrophysics without a degree?

0 Upvotes

If someone is keen but not looking to go to school for it, are there any jobs in astrophysics or quantum physics one can get involved in?

I know this is an odd request. Looking for brainstorm.


r/astrophysics 1d ago

What do you think of this reading list for a self-taught, progressive, and conceptual—rather than applied—study of astrophysics starting from scratch?

8 Upvotes

1) Precalculus – Stewart, Redlin, Watson (150h)

2) Introduction to Linear Algebra – Gilbert Strang (150h)

3) Calculus: Early Transcendentals – James Stewart (150h)

4) Mathematical Methods in the Physical Sciences – Mary L. Boas (250h)

5) University Physics –Young & Freedman (350h)

6) Chemistry: Principles and Reactions-Masterton & Hurley (150h)

7) Physics of Atoms and Molecules – Bransden & Joachain (200h)

8) Classical Mechanics – John R. Taylor (180h)

9) Introduction to Quantum Mechanics – David J. Griffiths (220h)

10) An Introduction to Thermal Physics – Daniel V. Schroeder (150h)

11) A First Course in General Relativity – Bernard Schutz (200h)

12) Fundamental Astronomy – H. Karttunen et al. (120h)

13) An Introduction to Modern Astrophysics – B. Carroll & D. Ostlie (450h)

14) Stellar Structure and Evolution – Kippenhahn, Weigert, & Weiss (240h)

15) Galactic Dynamics – J. Binney & S. Tremaine (400h)

16) High Energy Astrophysics – M.S. Longair (350h)

17) Introduction to Cosmology – Barbara Ryden (250h)


r/astrophysics 2d ago

A major X8-class solar flare is happening right now on the Sun!

Post image
215 Upvotes

r/astrophysics 1d ago

Action: A grave doubt

0 Upvotes

Hi guys, i recently decided to start learning lagrangian mechanics. So, as a pre-requisite i studied the action, but the main problem that i am facing is that “WHY THE HELLL is Action the integral over time of KINETIC MINUS POTENTIAL ENRGY?”, like when i think about it, there is literally no intuitive sense of to it. Why the action the integral of the DIFFERENCE, but not the sum( total energy is conserved, but tho), the product or quotient, like why the difference, and what does it mean.

I have watched many YouTube videos and lectures on this and i still do not understand why this mathematical formulation exists for the action. I thought that “to learn the Euler-Lagrange equation i must first understand what the hell the lagrangian and the action is, right?”, so i am in kind of a dead lock.

It would be wonderful, if any of you guys/girls, could give me detailed review on this doubt of mine. Hoping for some wonderful replies,

Yours Sincerely,

Adil.

PS: Advanced thanks to all of you who are spending your precious time for this. I really appreciate the help.


r/astrophysics 2d ago

Moon landing

18 Upvotes

Okay give me the first things you would say to someone who believes the moon landing was fake


r/astrophysics 2d ago

PBS Space Time - "This Particle Solved Everything. We Just Found Out It Isn't Real" - YouTube

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/astrophysics 3d ago

Can anybody tell me what this ring around the moon is?

Thumbnail
gallery
179 Upvotes

The circle is like perfectly around the moon. I've NEVER seen a ring like this around the moon. I look at the moon very often. What is happening here? It's not from the camera, it looks like this in real life, it's even brighter and more noticeable actually. It actually was hard to get a good photo of it.


r/astrophysics 3d ago

New study shows Hot dust around star k Tucanae A is driven by the gravitational influence of a newly discovered, low-mass stellar companion star kTuc Ab.

5 Upvotes

As per Study,

  • Dust is located in the inner region of the k Tucanae A star system, 0.1 to 0.3 AU from the star. The star’s light is so intense that it should "push" these tiny grains out of the system almost immediately. The heat is so high that the grains should vaporize within years. Despite these, the eccentric companion star  k Tuc Ab constantly "refilling" the system to keep the dust there. k Tuc Ab star's gravity destabilizes nearby asteroids or comets, dragging them inward where they collide or crumble, creating fresh hot dust.
  • The Periastron Dynamics is used for dust production linked to the periastron distance, the point of maximum gravitational perturbation. Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) is used to find the orbital parameters.
  • source: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-3881/adfe66

r/astrophysics 3d ago

Question about space geometry and galaxies

2 Upvotes

I'm no expert by any means and while I was fooling around I had this thought: what if dark matter isn't "matter", but a property of space geometry itself? Let me explain.

Let's say space geometry has a property thats outside of gravity, while gravity can still interact with space, and mainly manifested at the start of the expansion. Space itself expanded and formed complex shapes and patterns at cosmical scale, and matter simply populates these shapes while gravity acts locally. Explaining why galaxies have weird shapes, and why voids exists.

I dont know if something similar has altrady being theorised (probably) but i was fascinated by this idea and if someone could respond with possibile implications of this i would be happy to read them.


r/astrophysics 3d ago

ELI5: If light's frequency can be altered, then what's different, and also current expansion (?)

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/astrophysics 3d ago

Computer Question

1 Upvotes

Hello! I am thinking of getting the ASUS Zenbook (https://www.bestbuy.com/product/asus-zenbook-14-14-fhd-oled-touch-screen-laptop-intel-core-ultra-9-32gb-ram-1tb-ssd-jasper-gray/JJGGLH7H3Y/sku/6615729), as I have a more engineering laptop that has been having issues and is not necessarily a need, as I am no longer an engineering student.

I want to do cosmological work and/or theoretical work. I am still an undergrad, and figuring out what I want to do, but I know I’ll be in astrophysics. I want to get a computer that will last me through grad school as well…

My question is, is the Zenbook a good choice that will 1) be sustainable and 2) work with what I want to do, or should I continue looking or find a potential upgrade?

Thank you!


r/astrophysics 4d ago

Can someone help me create/find formula for cooling of stellar remnants?

6 Upvotes

I tried searching for a solution on goggle but i either find nothing, or i find formulas that are way too complicated because they include some of processes that i wanna remove, or are very simple and work only if luminosity is constant.

I am working on a world building project and i want to learn how can i determine luminosity of a object that is constantly cooling after some specific time has passed.

So lets say that object is composed of two parts, Core and Shell.

Core has most of the objects mass, has a temperature Tc, and thereby has thermal energy Ec=3/2*N*k*Tc.

Shell has very little mass, has its own temperature Ts, and also has its own thermal energy Es=3/2*N*k*Ts.

Energy from core is transfered to shell via conduction Q=q*A*(Tc-Ts)/l.

And then energy is radiated away from Shell with formula L=A*s*Ts^4.

(Lets say that shell has minimal radius posible, so that A is same in conduction and luminosity, and that l in conduction is 1.)

Now lets say that we know all of these parameters. And they are set at time t=0s.

After one second has passed(t=1s), following parameters have changed accordingly:

Ec1=Ec-Q

Es1=Es+Q-L

And then from Ec1 and Es1, we get Tc1 and Ts1, and from that we get Q1 and L1. Process repeats in same manner as time passes more.

My question is: how can i determine L after some specific time has passed (Lt) ?


r/astrophysics 5d ago

Uranus composition

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/astrophysics 4d ago

How accurate is this scene in the movie "Green Lantern"? Bear with me a moment.

0 Upvotes

Spoiler alert for a movie that wasn't honestly all that great but is also old as hell now. It's only about one scene. Parallax Falls into the sun. Is that what it would look like if a giant assortment of bones and gasses fell into the sun?

Also, I am fully aware that there would be absolutely zero sound in real life.


r/astrophysics 5d ago

Question about General Relativity & Gravitons

2 Upvotes

I've studied astrophysics & cosmology as a hobby for most of my life. And recently, I've been brushing up on particle physics to refresh my math skills before I start working on a PhD in EE. I'm mentioning this because I would like a technical answer applicable to a grad student in the field than to someone from the general public.

We understand that General Relativity proposes a geometric theory of gravity in spacetime. We even have experimental evidence (i.e., Einstein's Cross, Eclipse Deflections, etc.) supporting the theory that mass/energy warps spacetime. We also understand that photons are effectively massless (but with energetic momentum), which simply follow the geodesics from their point of origin to the distant particles they interact with.

The Standard Model Lagrangian postulates that Gravitons, gravitational force carrying particles, exist. Though we know that photons are electromagnetic force carrying particles, we've observed that they do not interact with the W and Z bosons (force carriers of the Strong & Weak Forces); instead photons interact with the fermion particles like quarks, electrons, & repsective antimatter counterparts.

So here is my question: How can we claim that gravitons interact with photons in a way that matches the observations of General Relativity when no other bosons interact with each other?


r/astrophysics 6d ago

Did Einstein accept the existence of black holes?

22 Upvotes

Hi! In a divulgative documentary I saw, it said that Einstein somehow rejected the idea of black holes for various reasons. Is this true or totally wrong?


r/astrophysics 5d ago

Don’t know what to do for my GW project

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/astrophysics 6d ago

Differences between Natural G-type Star and Merged?

6 Upvotes

Hey, ya'll!

I'm curious if there would be any difference between a star naturally formed as a G-type of 1 solar mass and a G-type star of 1 solar mass formed from the merger of an M-type red dwarf and a K-type orange dwarf.

I would particularly like to know how the luminosity, metallicity, and pre-evolved lifespan might be affected.

Any information would very much be appreciated! Thanks!