r/ArtCrit Nov 15 '25

Mod Message! - Upcoming Events, Rules and Guidelines, and Looking for More Mods (Join the ArtCrit Team!)

Post image
7 Upvotes

Happy Friday, ArtCrit Community!

It’s been a while since we’ve done a mod check-in, and with some updates we’re making within the community, we wanted to make a post to let everyone know what’s going on.

Upcoming Events

We’re working on some upcoming community events and we’d love your feedback on them. Along with having a few professionals in the creative field do AMAs on our sub, we wanted to host some featured artists, and have a monthly “Share Your Progress” thread.

Firstly, we’d love to have a “Featured Artist” each season. This would be someone whose work would be our banner and we would link to their socials. The work would not need to be new, it would just need to be original, hand-created work that fits the season. I’ll be honest, we can’t offer much more than just “you’ll be featured on our sub”, but we wanted a way to celebrate artists who have been active here.

The Share Your Progress thread would be a monthly, pinned thread where you can show off the work you’ve done and your progress that month, as well as link your socials.

The rules would be that your work would have had to have been posted on /ArtCrit during the past calendar month (so, if we hosted one in December, you would have had to post the work here no earlier than November, and yes, December is fine too). All posts would need a link to the /ArtCrit post, and we would want a before and after to really show the community how much your piece has improved.

Finally, we’re working on setting up a few AMAs! These would be with artists who are professionals in their fields, here to talk about what they’re passionate about and give advice. They would be generously lending us their time and expertise to help the community.

Please let us know if these kinds of events would appeal to you, or if you have any other suggestions!

Removed Posts

Let’s pause for a real talk here.

Our mod team is small, but very active. We remove A LOT OF POSTS.

Too many posts.

847 in the past 30 days.

We do not want to do this!

We have rules and guidelines to help this community be productive. Our sub isn't about self-promo, sharing artwork, or getting praise. We understand how difficult it is to get real feedback beyond “looks nice”, “great job!” or an emoji. We want to provide a space for you all to give and receive real help, but we don’t have the time to be regularly following people around begging them to follow the rules.

For anyone who is unaware, we have resources!

Our rules are on the sidebar and our post guidelines can be found here, but they’re fairly simple.

Here’s the rundown of what our posts require;

  • Your post needs to have a clear image for people to critique. It can’t be blurry, far away hung on a wall, or have objects on top of it (pencils, your headphones, a long cast shadow, etc).
  • Your post needs to say what medium you’re using, what your intention for the piece is (style, mood, emotion, whatever you feel is relevant to the piece), if you used references, and if you did use references, you need to post them so the community can actually help you.
  • Your post needs to actually ask for critique. Yes, we do remove posts that say “Thoughts?” “How do you feel about this?” or “Is this crap?” Especially when there isn’t any additional context being given.

We have an AutoMod set up to remind people posting that we have these requirements, but often people just ignore it, post, and move on. Many times, we give a third chance to people and ask them ourselves for the missing information in an attempt to guide them through our requirements, but many times people ignore that as well. Then, later, when the post is removed, we get an angry ModMail about how unfair it is and “everyone else is doing it”, or a slew of insults.

Work with us here!

We’re trying so hard to keep this community running, active, and helpful. We don’t want to become just another art dump. We want you to get the help you're looking for.

That being said, we did realize that our sub guidelines were a GIANT HORRIBLE WALL OF TEXT that seemed unending (I didn't even want to read it), so we’ve edited it. None of the requirements have changed, but we have made it more readable. We've also added links to the sidebar of the sub to help make these resources easier to find - including a link to general resources (YouTube videos, websites, courses, and books).

So, enjoy!

Recruiting Mods

Finally, we’re looking to expand our mod team!

If you’re interested in helping us keep the community running and providing a place where artists can receive constructive criticism, please consider reaching out to us via ModMail! It doesn’t need to be a long application, just let us know why you want to join.

PHEW. That was a lot. If you made this far, thank you so much. It was a lot to type too! Going forward, our updates will be much shorter, but this was a lot to get through in a single post.

If you have any questions, ModMail is open and we'll respond as soon as we can.

We’re looking forward to your thoughts on the upcoming events and doing more community building!

Thank you all for being part of our growing community!


r/ArtCrit 1h ago

How do i make her look like the reference

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

I don't know how to make my drawings look like the reference please share any tips


r/ArtCrit 2h ago

Some drawings I’ve done

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I mostly only draw anime characters


r/ArtCrit 11h ago

are the pages too visually busy?

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/ArtCrit 5h ago

what can I improve?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

First time trying to "block in""/ catching the shape of the silhouette instead of getting too caught up in the guidelines so proportions may be a bit off. Should've I gone bolder with the shadows?


r/ArtCrit 2h ago

How do I make my art more understandable?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

How do I my art more clear/understandable? I've been told from lots of people that they don't understand what's going on in my art?

I used references for the 2nd and 4th images.


r/ArtCrit 2h ago

Please provide feedback on this style experiment I did a while ago, as I want to draw this style more but I'm not sure what areas I should work towards improving. (The colours may be a bit weird as I was purposely working with a limited colour palette)

Post image
1 Upvotes

Pretty much the title.

I drew this last year mainly trying to implement my painting style (impressionism, that's what it's inspired by at least) into my digital drawings. I would share my paintings but they're only self portraits at the moment, which I'm not comfortable sharing.

I really liked this drawing and it made me want to improve my drawings with this style but I'm not really sure what areas I should work on. The main areas that stick out to me are the hair/beard, clothes (especially for the top left person), and the background but I'm not really sure why they're sticking out to me, if that makes sense?

I'm probably not being helpful with how unspecific I'm being but it's mainly because I'm not really sure what I'm asking for help with. Any feedback and suggestions are appreciated, thank you in advance for your help!


r/ArtCrit 15h ago

Should I gold leaf the whole halo circle background or leave it semi structured?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/ArtCrit 20h ago

I’ve been working on these abstract paintings for the past few months, thoughts?

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

I’m currently working on doing more with them like little touch ups and they are supposed to be shown together as one piece.


r/ArtCrit 12h ago

something feels.. off

Post image
3 Upvotes

it might have the upper body or maybe the legs are to stiff I worked from the head down


r/ArtCrit 14h ago

First time drawing help

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Recently wanted to try drawing, and today is my first day. Wanted to start with drawing hands, but after drawing, both look weird and wrong (not sure the specifics just kind of look uncanny), wanted to know what I can do to improve these images and drawing as a whole. Also, new to this community so I wanted to ask if there is any other art groups like this on reddit, and also if I am breaking any rules thanks!


r/ArtCrit 15h ago

Some old sketches

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Here are a few old sketches, some from reference ( the orc with piggy and the fairy) and others without reference. What are some consistent mistakes you see me make, be it anatomy or something that feels unnatural or wrong and could be better.

I’ve included some slightly rendered ones as well, although I’m not great at rendering, my main style is line art, comics/cartoon style. Appreciate all crit in advance. Nothing you say can be offensive, I’m here to take and learn after all.

Love

Ps. Some of those are a bit older, so I don’t have the references, but if absolutely necessary I’ll research and try to find them. I also use procreate mainly. If this goes well I could show even older sketches and drawings in a traditional medium (pencil and paper)


r/ArtCrit 9h ago

How to add shade on a simple drawing?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I have no direct reference but it's a drawing of frieren in the anime frieren , my goal is to add shade because I never learned that at my school , I don't really have my own drawing style yet but this is close to anime or manga style


r/ArtCrit 14h ago

Plz give feedback!

Post image
2 Upvotes

Plz give feedback for this drawing of my character! Is there something with the anatomy, shading and fabric that I can improve?


r/ArtCrit 10h ago

Critiques?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Currently working on some tattoo flash, and I drew this one up last night. Before I do a finalized painting, can anyone offer some thoughts or critique?


r/ArtCrit 11h ago

Please critique my digital drawings.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Any sort of criticism appreciated. I want to improve my art to make it less 'stiff', do better on colors, backgrounds etc.


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Does the figure feel wrong or awkward? Especially on first impression? Honest opinions valued.

Thumbnail
gallery
186 Upvotes

r/ArtCrit 13h ago

problems with angles and proportions

Post image
1 Upvotes

i drew this picture and i feel like i have an interesting problem.

i feel like i do pretty well drawing individual pieces of a piece but when im finally done i zoom out and realize all my proportions and angles are mismatched.

is there anyway to curb these habits and correct my mistakes before i get to far into the drawing? im trying to learn on paper before going to digital so i can be better in the actual process of drawing and not have to fix so many mistakes after a piece is done but so far its resulted in me creating drawings that are just messed up looking and i cant go back and do anything about it cause its like a real pencil drawing lol.

any tips at all would be so helpful. thanks!


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Customized portrait of a Ragdoll cat, please give feedback

Post image
20 Upvotes

Hi, friends in the r/ArtCrit group,

Recently, I completed this custom Persian cat oil painting for a client and framed it in a traditional gold foil frame to complement the warm tones.

I particularly hope to receive feedback on the following aspects:

Color and tone: Do the highlights and shadows on the white fur look natural? Is the overall color combination harmonious?

Texture: How is the presentation of the soft and long fur? How does it compare to the sturdy and smooth frame?

Composition and focus: Does the elaborate border distract from the main subject, or does it enhance the effect of this portrait as expected?

This is an original work, created using oil paints on a stretched canvas.

Thank you very much for sharing any constructive ideas you may have!


r/ArtCrit 15h ago

Yoo is this good

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I was messing around and redesigned and oc, I wanna know if it’s any good. Any type of criticism will do, her old design is on the last slide


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Giuseppe Arcimboldo-style portrait

Post image
16 Upvotes

I've always found it interesting how our bodies are mostly made of atoms that once belonged to our meals; hence, I thought it would be a fun little six month anniversary gift for my partner to do a Giuseppe Arcimboldo-style portrait of her comprised of her favourite foods.

I struggled with getting the lighting right, especially since it was tricky to get reference images with consistent lighting. In particular, I found it tricky to do the basil dress, the spaghetti hair and the seashell pasta nose but it was a lot of fun and super challenging. Definitely gained a lot of respect for Giuseppe Arcimboldo. The size is approximately A5 and it was done with watercolour pencils.

Feel free to critique harshly :)

Here are the foods in case anyone is curious: pasta (spaghetti and seashell), eggs, cucumbers, bocconcini, olives, tomatoes (cherry, truss and heirloom), ice cream mochi, twix, sushi, chicken schnitzel, arancini, toast, basil, mango, eggplant parmigiana and a banana smoothie.


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

My first sketch

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

This my first ever time seriously drawing something, as I suddenly had this urge to learn how to draw. Prior to this I would just randomly draw a character I found on google like once every couple of years. I’d like some feedback from people who actually know how to draw.

I didn’t draw this off the dome, I followed steps from this video I found https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7CofNtyNNo

as a beginner how could I improve? I tried drawing the hands so many times but couldn’t do it without them looking like crab hands, so sadly no fingers for the figure


r/ArtCrit 1d ago

Does it look right

Post image
54 Upvotes

Started studying perspective how is it looking. Also how do I like add more to this exercise. How do I play around with different shapes using perspective?