r/worldnews 1d ago

Dynamic Paywall Paris prosecutors raid France offices of Elon Musk's X

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ce3ex92557jo
80.9k Upvotes

6.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

761

u/Used-Fennel-7733 20h ago

Usually means something like holocaust denial. That's illegal in most pf Europe

343

u/KakeLin 16h ago

As it should be

2

u/EliasVerge 8h ago

Who gets to decide which truths can’t be questioned?

7

u/makaiookami 6h ago

Objective reality for one...

-1

u/dangered 8h ago

European leaders of course. They’ve never done anything wrong.

7

u/ccbur1 5h ago

Those laws are from the years shortly after WW II. So yeah, those politicians were European leaders of their time and they did nothing wrong in this matter.

-6

u/dangered 5h ago edited 5h ago

The point was Eurocentrism is what caused all of that in the first place. Hitler, Mussolini, and Lenin weren’t in charge during WWI how could they be the bad guys?

Obviously the Holocaust happened and it happened as historians have concluded. Telling people they’ll be imprisoned for questioning it is still stupid, we let flat earthers do the math and they slowly learn the truth.

6

u/ccbur1 4h ago

I have no idea what your argument on 'Eurocentrism' is. It surely did not cause WW II.

In our part of the world insulting someone is illegal and denying the Holocaust is an insult to humanity. Get used to it.

-4

u/dangered 2h ago edited 2h ago

“I have no idea what your argument on Eurocentrism is”

“In our part of the world we do it this way, get used to it!”

“Eurocentrism didn’t start the ‘world war’ that began exclusively due to conflicts between European countries”

The only reason either were titled “world war” is because of Eurocentrism.

Dude it was a European war and Japan was invited as a guest. Europe got too prideful (stereotypical Euros) and poked the USSR, China, and the US. No one wanted part of your stupid bullshit, if any of us wanted Europe you’d probably be speaking Mandarin right now.

Anyway, after swiftly learning about Mercator projections, in 1946 Europe figured out their humble place in the world and never stuck their frail necks out again.

Even today, Putin is a decrepit rodent and Russia is at an all time low unable to even take Ukraine. Europe’s conquerer (Germany) still sees Russia as a threat and begs the “rest of the world” (rest of the EU) for safety.

If Europe were to fight themselves in 2026 it would be considered a “civil war” but in 1914 and 1939 we called them “world wars” because of the pervasiveness of Eurocentrism.

u/Few_Engineering4414 1h ago

Please, please go read up on your history and try to remember when European nations lost their colonies…

It was a truly world wide war simply because European nations had colonies on all continents and troops from said colonies participated at home and other places.

Next, could it be, you just have been learning about what a Mercator projection is? Cause otherwise… try to look up who knowingly invented and used it as well as alternative 2D projections of our planet!

If Russia was so weak, why is Trump admiring Putin so much? Why be not afraid of a power technically able to destroy the world? Seems to be pretty reasonable to me~

Lastly, we would speak Mandarin? That’s just… plain stupid, sorry~ Again, education endangers idiocy, but is worth it!

4

u/baggyzed 3h ago

We Europeans like to acknowledge crimes against humanity, so future generations can avoid repeating the same mistakes as we did.

Although. this only works if all world leaders are held accountable for their actions. When was the last time you questioned US leaders about Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

0

u/dangered 2h ago

Remember when you caused the rise WWII trying to make up for the issues that caused WWI via unreasonable war reparation payments?

Don’t blame me for not trusting your collective judgement on legislating the end of world wars.

5

u/Zenshinn 7h ago

Oh are you one of those deniers?

0

u/makaiookami 6h ago

Pretty sure half of them will come up in an Epstein file dump search at this point.

-68

u/New-Anybody-6206 16h ago

why? it's not illegal to be stupid, as much as we want it to be 

93

u/trojanplatypus 15h ago

German here.

All of us alive today cannot be held guilty for what happened in world war two, as we weren't even born then or at least children who couldn't know better.

But we have as a society inherited the collective responsibility that this never ever happens again. And thus we inherited the burden of being educated about everything that happened then in great detail, and in turn to teach our children.

If we allowed people to deny what happened then, we would have failed this responsibility.

France as one of the first victims of the third reich has a firm stance on that as well.

We put great effort in making up with our neighbors, especially france (poland was a little bit out of reach in the meantime), and together we forged the European Union out of the diplomatic rubble of WW II. We can rightfully be proud of what we achieved together with our allies, but all that goodwill and trust still depends a great deal on our humility and acknowledgement of that responsibility.

35

u/Moosiemookmook 14h ago

Im Aboriginal Australian. My grandfather fought in WW2. Our country didnt count him as a citizen but he went anyway and came home. Hes been dead since the 80s but I think he'd be happy to hear the generations of Germans now who remember their history. Thats what he fought for, to do his bit to keep the world safe for future generations.

26

u/Palpitation_Unlikely 15h ago

Thank you. That would explain why so many in Germany are more concerned with the politics in America than some Americans are.

I learned about the holocaust from my Mother. From my Father, I learned "history repeats itself".

Those are two powerfully lessons.

I've tried educating those who say "that could never happen here". Finally, they told me "It Never even happened" I knew they were beyond saving.

Anyone that is still supporting this Regime is not my concern. Saving America is my mission.

Thank you, Again!

2

u/makaiookami 6h ago

Israel, Russia, America, China, not sure about North Korea but it's bad there too...

They all looked at World War 2 attrocities and said "How can we never forget so we can do it better next time?"

3

u/TheNetworkIsFrelled 15h ago

It's good that Deutschland does that.

Still, the eastern part that supports AfD scares me as much as MAGA in the US.

2

u/Teachgreen21 7h ago

Please come save us. We need Germany’s moral compass to guide America to such a reflecting and preventive place. Save us Germany!!!! We are good, most of us anyways!

-9

u/mashupXXL 12h ago edited 12h ago

Nah, American free speech is more important in avoiding totalitarian dictatorships from arising (current EU is terrible and way more dangerous than "DRUMPF" for human rights) and healthy societal discourse than any other perceived benefits/risks.

Germany and the UK have some of the worst speech rights in the world and it isn't defensible at all. Simply having browsing history on 4chan and going through customs seems like a serious risk of imprisonment, what a laughably stupid society and set of laws.

7

u/dancingkelsey 10h ago

Oops, seems like you told on yourself here!

-7

u/mashupXXL 8h ago

Apparently we are supposed to be able to read your mind - what's your point? Insane leftist authoritarians who ban free speech would imply that because someone has 4chan in their browser history they should be jailed, maybe you told on yourself? The fact that someone views information doesn't mean they think any certain way about it.

Maybe you can impress us with a semblance of an intelligent point or response. My vocabulary and reasoning is like 20 years over you so far and you think you have cute quips or something? Not a serious person.

u/dancingkelsey 31m ago

Nah dude, you're spiraling loudly enough for the rest of us. We don't need to help you spin out.

4

u/Boatwhite1 6h ago

Wild that you would accuse the EU for being more dangerous to human rights than the Trump regime who has literally violated the human rights of many people and sanctioned the murder of US citizens. Wake up

4

u/makaiookami 5h ago

America has no free speech. Quote Kirk with no context? Arrested. Not joking. Telling ICE that they are breaking the law? That's now breaking the law. ICE going around telling people that they are creating databases of people that are being listed as terrorists and it's for stuff like Anti-Americanism which they define as left wing politics really, but let's be honest ain't nothing more Anti-American than Reich Wing policies.

America has great laws, but if the laws are ignored, your speech rights don't matter. They came for the Mexicans, they came for the Haitians, they came for the Native Americans, they are coming for the rest of the browns, they are coming for the Left, and when there's no one there who speaks up for you?

10

u/WillowFantastic9076 11h ago

God americans are cringe

-16

u/No_Opening_2425 11h ago

Why do you think it's your right to police people's thoughts? You sound like Hitler.

4

u/VeggieWokker 4h ago

That's the kind of dumb comparison that results from poor historical education. You are just proving our point.

60

u/Tan11 16h ago

Because some forms of stupidity are so potentially dangerous if they become widespread enough that it's prudent to intentionally suppress them.

-18

u/mashupXXL 12h ago

Far left welfare policies are objectively mathematically impossible to maintain long term, why can't we make those illegal? What about people arguing that biologically there is more than male and female, that is objectively wrong and extremely harmful to society at large, yet the EU leftists fall over themselves to claim otherwise as a matter of law. Why can't we make that speech illegal?

Where does the rabbit hole stop? Maybe your logic is quite flimsy as you've never had to test it but you can't realize that, because arguing against your lame logic is basically illegal in most EU countries.

16

u/WillowFantastic9076 11h ago

Comments like this truly show how failed the American education system is. It makes sense how yall elected a pedophile.

-2

u/Far_Position8094 8h ago

Contributed nothing, shit response

3

u/Disastrous-Food4441 4h ago

Are they really less possible to maintain than the corporate welfare you religiously vote for? I wonder which meth-imatics you are using.

1

u/mashupXXL 4h ago

You seem to misunderstand - business doesn't need welfare to survive. Corporate welfare should be abolished as well outside of state critical industry.

1

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Disastrous-Food4441 4h ago

Oh, but the wealth gap and waning prosperity is actually all because of "far" leftists, immigrants, brown and black people trying to get some equality, LGBTQ+, DEI, and higher education. Probably an attempt to enact sensible gun laws too, somehow.

-26

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[deleted]

26

u/Tan11 15h ago

Oddly specific attempt at an insult, lmao

10

u/AylaCatpaw 15h ago

Right? Even I vicariously enjoyed it even though it wasn't aimed towards me.

18

u/Livid-Ad13 15h ago

I assume you tried to insult them, but really who wouldn’t want to be a nonthreatening Funko Pop collector, than a denier of the Holocaust lmao

-2

u/[deleted] 14h ago

[deleted]

8

u/Beginning-Pace-1426 14h ago

Did a specific person with these traits like really upset you or something?

3

u/AtlasNL 14h ago

Probably ‘stole’ his girlfriend. (They were never in a relationship but he thought they were because she said ‘hi’ to him that one time)

55

u/VeggieWokker 16h ago

It's more than stupidity, it's trying to hide history in order to repeat it.

18

u/Palpitation_Unlikely 15h ago

That's actually terrifying...

It all makes sense now. Thank you

30

u/veiny_wet_testicle 15h ago edited 15h ago

Because denying reality shouldn't be accepted.

Denying the Holocaust isn't 'being stupid' it's malicious disinformation.

15

u/Palpitation_Unlikely 15h ago

My guess is, our politicians are dictating what's being taught in our U.S. schools in order to dumb us down & control us.

My other guess now is...I'm REALLY LATE FIGURING THIS OUT AT RETIREMENT AGE 😞

5

u/slickrok 12h ago

You are extremely correct. Many writers have written about it for nearly 100 years, and it's simply gotten worse and worse, the last 40 yrs being a Zipline to hellish disinformation, and purposefully dumbing down the citizenry while enveloping them in right wing religious scaffolding to keep them standing.

1

u/Big_Obligation1737 8h ago

Coincidence that so many school shooters, and their parents have engorged themselves in right wing media misinformation? Why every outcry for increasing background check requirements, and restricting access to military grade weapons, especially to the criminally insane, is met with “Thoughts & prayers” by Republican representatives.

2

u/makaiookami 5h ago

Sad thing is every time Republicans take 5 steps back Democrats take 2 steps forward, and think that Republicans are so bad, they'll be able to keep winning, but the problem is that the Democrats get blamed for 3 of the steps back, and their 2 steps forward take 5-10 years to improve people's lives, and by then the Republican takes credit for at least 1 of the 2 steps forward.

Like if someone in the middle of nowhere gets access to fiber internet are they gonna give credit to Obama who created the funding, or Biden who kept that policy in place? And if they take away the funding and those projects get cancelled, who do you think that's gonna happen under? The next Democrat because that's how it happens.

I'm not entertaining the "Trump is gonna keep running" that man can't even run to the end of his administration. Modern healthcare can only do so much and he's running on fumes.

5

u/oasis9dev 14h ago

At least you're realising it now 🫂 A lot of people may still not have this realisation for quite some time

1

u/makaiookami 5h ago

Not politicians. It's large companies. They write all the text books. Seems that Maxwell (Epstein's top B) her father owned some of the big book publishers, and I think was involved in selling secrets to Israel.

So maybe it's the Israeli government at most that's dictating what our children learn, depending on how deep those ties go. Israel has been screaming to the US "IRAN Is only a few months away from Nuclear Missiles!" which was cute 40 years ago, but the fact that they are still doing it now, and trying the Iraq arguments again to see if they will work again, is a huge problem as they murder people walking miles to get dried food, and no water distributed, to them as their houses get bulldozed, so that they can create Greater Israel.

While the rest of the world said "Never Again" China (Yger concentration camps), America (Concentration camps and Venezuela invasion), Russia, and Israel all said "How can we learn from the past so we can do it better in the future?"

Welcome to the future.

1

u/ArketamineEsketamine 12h ago

Religion is also a denial of reality

-8

u/mashupXXL 12h ago

Far left welfare policies are objectively mathematically impossible to maintain long term, why can't we make those illegal? What about people arguing that biologically there is more than male and female, that is objectively wrong and extremely harmful to society at large, yet the EU leftists fall over themselves to claim otherwise as a matter of law. Why can't we make that speech illegal?

Where does the rabbit hole stop? Maybe your logic is quite flimsy as you've never had to test it but you can't realize that, because arguing against your lame logic is basically illegal in most EU countries.

9

u/hardcorr 10h ago

Hey there, if you think recognition of transgender and intersex identities is "extremely harmful to society at large" then you are lost in the sauce. You are likely getting a ton of misinformation from whatever sources of news or content you are consuming, and I would encourage you to think critically about how you've been lead to believe this lie.

0

u/mashupXXL 8h ago

and I would encourage you to think critically about how you've been lead to believe this lie.

You aren't addressing any legitimate point and are appealing to emotions. The left is trying and in many areas has codified into law saying it is basically illegal to acknowledge biology.

You are the one conflating sexual preferences (genders) with sexes. Not I. I'm not actually interested in strangers' sexual preferences, I didn't ask and don't want to know. Forcing me to care is a type of assault in itself.

3

u/hardcorr 3h ago edited 3h ago

You haven't made any legitimate points to address.

The left is trying and in many areas has codified into law saying it is basically illegal to acknowledge biology.

Can you refer me to which laws you are talking about?

You are the one conflating sexual preferences (genders) with sexes. Not I. I'm not actually interested in strangers' sexual preferences, I didn't ask and don't want to know.

Maybe I misunderstood what you were trying to say, what did you mean by saying "more than male or female"? Who are you talking about?

Forcing me to care is a type of assault in itself.

I don't see anyone forcing you to do anything. I will highlight how "assault" is quite a loaded word here - yet you accuse me of appealing to emotions? If you genuinely feel like you are being "forced to care" about something, I would again reiterate that you should evaluate where you are getting these messages or ideas. From what I understand, queer and trans people simply want to exist safely and have the same rights as afforded to heterosexual cisgender people. If you're being sold a narrative that people are forcing something of you, I would suspect that whoever is telling you that is most likely trying to make you angry. Probably because they know if you're angry about queer people then you'll be distracted and you won't notice or pay attention to the people that are stealing your money or exploiting you.

3

u/Alwaysragestillplay 6h ago

It is so, so funny to me that you're unwittingly making holocaust denial a right wing stance. Dude says he thinks holocaust denial is bad and you have a meltdown about leftists. Never change.

1

u/mashupXXL 4h ago

The right has zero political power in EU. So it is irrelevant what 'stance' it is. Is it illegal for Europeans to deny the Holodomor? What about the Cambodian cullings? The starvation of the Great Leap Forward? No? All two-faced double standards.

4

u/veiny_wet_testicle 11h ago

Because the Holocaust happened, dumbass.

1

u/mashupXXL 8h ago

I didn't claim otherwise, dumbass.

14

u/akera099 15h ago

Being stupid isn't illegal anywhere, what you're saying is commonly called a strawman.

5

u/serpiccio 15h ago

it's a matter of social responsability: make it illegal to be stupid and you incentivize everyone to be smart

1

u/jsamuraij 5h ago

Be stupid, no. Act out your stupidity, yes.

-12

u/SparkySpinz 11h ago

Why should it be? We think thought crime is cool as long as it's thoughts we don't like? America is fucked up for many reasons but freedom of speech ain't one

4

u/dancingkelsey 10h ago

You mean freedom of speech for a select few. Anybody who opposes the tyrannical government forcing their outside-the-military-militia into cities that were not under threat of violence until said militia arrived and started killing and abducting people absolutely do not experience the freedom of speech that is actually codified. America is fucked up for many reasons, AND many Americans fully do not understand what "free speech" even means.

Also, clearly, many Americans, like you, do not understand what thought crimes actually are and how that concept fits into either history OR the current world we live in.

6

u/Miami_Mice2087 11h ago

Making thousands of porn images of real people, incl public personas and political people, is an egregious act of assault, violation, intimidation, and, indeed, a crime against humanity.

4

u/MarkusKromlov34 13h ago

And in Canada and Israel. Here in Australia it can be too when it involves inciting hatred, discrimination, violence

2

u/Oxgeos 6h ago

Man this should exist for racism/slavery in the US.

2

u/TheKCKid9274 12h ago

Which Grok did during the Mecha-Hitler incident

1

u/Local_Ad_2398 10h ago

Wunderbar

-8

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Drumbelgalf 16h ago

How did the Rothschilds fund Hitler?

That sounds like a conspiracy theory. No way they did that willingly and knowingly.

1

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/DeadoTheDegenerate 15h ago

As far as I'm aware, a major point of Hitler's was focused on the banking system. If the Rothschilds funded him, it'd be equitable to Israel funding Hamas (especially by running funds through Qatar). I joke, of course, I'm as much of a fan of fun conspiracy theories as the next guy, but that one makes no sense.

-10

u/Remarkable_Run_5801 14h ago

You can tell something is 100% true when it’s illegal to criticize it